Subaru Forester Price in New York
As of September 29, 2026, there are 2,376 Subaru Forester vehicles available at 54 dealerships in New York. New York dealers are pricing competitively — the average selling price is $786 below MSRP, with 61% of inventory at or under sticker. 41 of 54 dealers are currently pricing below MSRP on average. Prices range from $28,844 to $47,886, with a median of $37,883.
These are advertised prices — a negotiated deal (incentives, dealer discounts) often beats them.
2,376
In Stock
-$786
Avg Markup
61.4%
At/Below MSRP
$37,883
Median Price
Price range: $28,844 to $47,886.
Dealers in New York
| Dealer | Count | Avg Markup | Below MSRP |
|---|---|---|---|
| East Hills Subaru of Sayville Sayville, NY | 26 | -$3,005 | 26 |
| Simmons Rockwell Subaru Elmira, NY | 31 | -$2,771 | 18 |
| Island Subaru Staten Island, NY | 28 | -$2,587 | 21 |
| Rye Subaru Rye, NY | 69 | -$2,279 | 69 |
| Maguire Subaru Ithaca, NY | 15 | -$2,163 | 14 |
| Curry Subaru Cortlandt Manor, NY | 69 | -$2,103 | 69 |
| Royal Subaru Cortland, NY | 20 | -$2,094 | 8 |
| Milea Subaru Bronx, NY | 25 | -$2,090 | 25 |
| Star Subaru Bayside, NY | 49 | -$1,932 | 48 |
| Ruge's Subaru Rhinebeck, NY | 59 | -$1,808 | 37 |
| Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru Orangeburg, NY | 9 | -$1,802 | 9 |
| Matthews Subaru Vestal, NY | 44 | -$1,689 | 24 |
| South Shore Subaru Lindenhurst, NY | 43 | -$1,603 | 27 |
| Grand Prix Subaru Hicksville, NY | 53 | -$1,544 | 53 |
| North Coast Subaru Glen Cove, NY | 15 | -$1,500 | 15 |
| Van Bortel Subaru of Rochester Rochester, NY | 65 | -$1,431 | 65 |
| Mid-Hudson Subaru Wappingers Falls, NY | 85 | -$1,407 | 65 |
| Van Bortel Subaru of Victor Victor, NY | 45 | -$1,378 | 45 |
| Curry Subaru Kingston Kingston, NY | 42 | -$1,297 | 42 |
| Zappone Subaru Norwich Norwich, NY | 21 | -$1,268 | 21 |
| Gregoris Subaru Valley Stream, NY | 33 | -$1,201 | 33 |
| Subaru of Utica Yorkville, NY | 78 | -$1,178 | 59 |
| Bay Ridge Subaru Brooklyn, NY | 25 | -$1,158 | 16 |
| Subaru White Plains Elmsford, NY | 47 | -$1,093 | 47 |
| Brewster Subaru Brewster, NY | 57 | -$971 | 54 |
| Prestige Subaru Pleasantville, NY | 24 | -$897 | 24 |
| East Hills Subaru Roslyn, NY | 56 | -$838 | 49 |
| Subaru of Troy Troy, NY | 62 | -$829 | 27 |
| Koeppel Subaru Long Island City, NY | 55 | -$712 | 53 |
| Romano Subaru Syracuse, NY | 97 | -$634 | 50 |
| Lacy Subaru Catskill, NY | 22 | -$571 | 8 |
| Hassett Subaru Wantagh, NY | 24 | -$367 | 13 |
| Riverhead Bay Subaru Riverhead, NY | 27 | -$359 | 27 |
| DELLA Subaru of Plattsburgh Plattsburgh, NY | 64 | -$254 | 64 |
| West Herr Subaru of Rochester Rochester, NY | 63 | -$169 | 20 |
| Tasca Subaru of Yonkers Yonkers, NY | 30 | -$133 | 6 |
| Romeo Subaru Saratoga Springs, NY | 39 | -$15 | 5 |
| Capitaland Subaru Glenville, NY | 49 | $0 | 49 |
| Five Star Subaru Oneonta, NY | 31 | $0 | 31 |
| Fox Subaru Auburn, NY | 23 | $0 | 6 |
| Barstow Subaru Potsdam, NY | 18 | $0 | 18 |
| West Herr Subaru of Lockport Lockport, NY | 39 | +$1 | 3 |
| Northtown Subaru Transit Depew, NY | 29 | +$57 | 2 |
| Competition Subaru of Smithtown St James, NY | 73 | +$136 | 3 |
| Parker Subaru Webster Webster, NY | 28 | +$146 | 1 |
| Bill Rapp Subaru Syracuse, NY | 67 | +$149 | 1 |
| Goldstein Subaru Colonie, NY | 85 | +$175 | 0 |
| Empire Subaru of Huntington Huntington, NY | 48 | +$175 | 0 |
| Johnstons Subaru Middletown, NY | 42 | +$175 | 0 |
| North Country Subaru Queensbury, NY | 39 | +$175 | 0 |
| Bob Johnson Subaru Watertown Watertown, NY | 30 | +$175 | 0 |
| Shults Subaru Jamestown, NY | 9 | +$175 | 0 |
| West Herr Subaru Orchard Park, NY | 87 | +$179 | 0 |
| Northtown Subaru Amherst, NY | 63 | +$193 | 1 |