Skip to content
← All dealers

Preston Toyota

New Castle, PA

Visit website →

Pricing posture

Prices above MSRP on some inventory

59% of this dealer's priced Toyota inventory is listed above MSRP — 74 of 125 vehicles.

Based on the advertised price in the manufacturer's public feed versus the factory window sticker. A dealer's final offer can differ. We only show this for brands whose feed publishes a real asking price that moves in both directions.

Vehicles

125

Avg Markup

-$657

At/Below MSRP

51

Models

17

Pricing by Model

ModelCountAt/Below MSRPAvg Markup
Tacoma2793%-$1,641
RAV4210%+$490
Tundra14100%-$3,949
Corolla130%+$490
4Runner944%+$46
Corolla Cross90%+$490
Camry729%-$124
Sienna60%+$490
Grand Highlander Hybrid40%+$490
4Runner Hybrid30%+$490
Grand Highlander333%-$177
Sequoia2100%-$2,510
Tacoma Hybrid250%-$1,307
Prius20%+$490
Highlander Hybrid10%+$490
GR Corolla1100%-$2,051
GR861100%-$728
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra Capstone 4WD

-$5,048Great Deal

Magnetic Gray Metallic

MSRP

$86,133

Advertised

$81,085

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra Platinum 4WD

-$4,410Good Deal

Blueprint

MSRP

$76,056

Advertised

$71,646

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra Platinum 4WD

-$4,151Good Deal

Wind Chill Pearl

MSRP

$73,567

Advertised

$69,416

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra 1794 Edition 4WD

-$4,132Good Deal

Wind Chill Pearl

MSRP

$73,894

Advertised

$69,762

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra 1794 Edition 4WD

-$4,105Good Deal

Midnight Black Metallic

MSRP

$73,518

Advertised

$69,413

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra 1794 Edition 4WD

-$4,105Good Deal

Celestial Silver Metallic

MSRP

$73,874

Advertised

$69,769

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra Platinum 4WD

-$4,099Good Deal

Lunar Rock

MSRP

$73,092

Advertised

$68,993

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra Platinum 4WD

-$4,099Good Deal

Magnetic Gray Metallic

MSRP

$73,092

Advertised

$68,993

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra Platinum 4WD

-$4,099Good Deal

Lunar Rock

MSRP

$73,092

Advertised

$68,993

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra 1794 Edition 4WD

-$4,089Good Deal

Lunar Rock

MSRP

$73,489

Advertised

$69,400

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra 1794 Edition 4WD

-$4,080Good Deal

Celestial Silver Metallic

MSRP

$73,419

Advertised

$69,339

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Off-Road 4WD

-$3,736Good Deal

Bronze Oxide

MSRP

$60,372

Advertised

$56,636

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra Limited 4WD

-$3,437Good Deal

Lunar Rock

MSRP

$63,833

Advertised

$60,396

New Castle, PA
Pre-SoldHold
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Sport 4WD

-$3,410Good Deal

Bronze Oxide

MSRP

$56,573

Advertised

$53,163

New Castle, PA
2027 Tacoma

2027 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Off-Road 4WD

-$3,392Good Deal

Underground

MSRP

$57,079

Advertised

$53,687

New Castle, PA
Hold
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Off-Road 4WD

-$3,361Good Deal

Ice Cap

MSRP

$56,678

Advertised

$53,317

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Sport 4WD

-$3,288Good Deal

Bronze Oxide

MSRP

$55,887

Advertised

$52,599

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Sport 4WD

-$3,288Good Deal

Celestial Silver Metallic

MSRP

$55,887

Advertised

$52,599

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Sport 4WD

-$3,235Good Deal

Underground

MSRP

$55,408

Advertised

$52,173

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma Hybrid

2026 Tacoma Hybrid

Tacoma TRD Sport 4WD

-$3,104Good Deal

Wind Chill Pearl

MSRP

$56,652

Advertised

$53,548

New Castle, PA
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra SR5 4WD

-$2,929Good Deal

Ice Cap

MSRP

$56,538

Advertised

$53,609

New Castle, PA
Hold
2026 Sequoia

2026 Sequoia

Sequoia Platinum 4WD

-$2,510Good Deal

Lunar Rock

MSRP

$85,993

Advertised

$83,483

New Castle, PA
2026 Sequoia

2026 Sequoia

Sequoia Platinum 4WD

-$2,509Good Deal

Wind Chill Pearl

MSRP

$86,468

Advertised

$83,959

New Castle, PA
Hold
2026 Tundra

2026 Tundra

Tundra TRD Pro 4WD

-$2,507Good Deal

Wave Maker

MSRP

$78,956

Advertised

$76,449

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma SR5 4WD

-$2,362Good Deal

Celestial Silver Metallic

MSRP

$47,153

Advertised

$44,791

New Castle, PA
Hold
2027 Tacoma

2027 Tacoma

Tacoma SR5 4WD

-$2,333Good Deal

Ice Cap

MSRP

$46,634

Advertised

$44,301

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Off-Road 4WD

-$2,246Good Deal

Ice Cap

MSRP

$47,423

Advertised

$45,177

New Castle, PA
2027 Tacoma

2027 Tacoma

Tacoma SR5 4WD

-$2,241Good Deal

Heritage Blue

MSRP

$45,948

Advertised

$43,707

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Sport 4WD

-$2,221Good Deal

Ice Cap

MSRP

$47,154

Advertised

$44,933

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma SR5 4WD

-$2,151Good Deal

Black

MSRP

$45,299

Advertised

$43,148

New Castle, PA
2027 Tacoma

2027 Tacoma

Tacoma SR5 4WD

-$2,089Good Deal

Ice Cap

MSRP

$45,004

Advertised

$42,915

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma SR5 4WD

-$2,055Good Deal

Supersonic Red

MSRP

$44,243

Advertised

$42,188

New Castle, PA
2026 GR Corolla

2026 GR Corolla

GR Corolla Premium Plus DAT AWD

-$2,051Good Deal

Ice Cap

MSRP

$51,224

Advertised

$49,173

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma SR5 4WD

-$2,000Good Deal

Underground

MSRP

$44,299

Advertised

$42,299

New Castle, PA
Hold
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma SR5 RWD

-$1,791Good Deal

Ice Cap

MSRP

$40,634

Advertised

$38,843

New Castle, PA
2026 Camry

2026 Camry

Camry SE FWD

-$1,692Good Deal

Supersonic Red

MSRP

$34,347

Advertised

$32,655

New Castle, PA
2027 Camry

2027 Camry

Camry SE FWD

-$1,627Good Deal

Ice Cap

MSRP

$33,909

Advertised

$32,282

New Castle, PA
2026 Grand Highlander

2026 Grand Highlander

Grand Highlander Platinum AWD

-$1,510Good Deal

Wind Chill Pearl

MSRP

$58,888

Advertised

$57,378

New Castle, PA
2027 GR86

2027 GR86

GR86 Premium AT RWD

-$728Good Deal

Trueno Blue

MSRP

$36,804

Advertised

$36,076

New Castle, PA
2026 4Runner

2026 4Runner

4Runner TRD Sport Premium PT4WD

-$510Good Deal

Underground

MSRP

$60,038

Advertised

$59,528

New Castle, PA
2026 4Runner

2026 4Runner

4Runner TRD Sport Premium PT4WD

-$510Good Deal

Wind Chill Pearl

MSRP

$60,293

Advertised

$59,783

New Castle, PA
2026 4Runner

2026 4Runner

4Runner Limited FT4WD

-$510Good Deal

Wind Chill Pearl

MSRP

$64,923

Advertised

$64,413

New Castle, PA
2026 4Runner

2026 4Runner

4Runner TRD Off-Road Premium PT4WD

-$510Good Deal

Ice Cap

MSRP

$59,723

Advertised

$59,213

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma SR5 4WD

-$10Good Deal

Underground

MSRP

$45,858

Advertised

$45,848

New Castle, PA
Hold
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Sport 4WD

-$10Good Deal

Celestial Silver Metallic

MSRP

$48,588

Advertised

$48,578

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Off-Road 4WD

-$10Good Deal

Bronze Oxide

MSRP

$47,613

Advertised

$47,603

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Off-Road 4WD

-$10Good Deal

Bronze Oxide

MSRP

$57,248

Advertised

$57,238

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Off-Road 4WD

-$10Good Deal

Supersonic Red

MSRP

$47,728

Advertised

$47,718

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma SR5 4WD

-$10Good Deal

Supersonic Red

MSRP

$44,158

Advertised

$44,148

New Castle, PA
Hold
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Sport 4WD

-$10Good Deal

Black

MSRP

$54,428

Advertised

$54,418

New Castle, PA
2026 Tacoma

2026 Tacoma

Tacoma TRD Sport 4WD

-$10Good Deal

Black

MSRP

$54,428

Advertised

$54,418

New Castle, PA
2026 RAV4

2026 RAV4

RAV4 Woodland AWD

+$490Fair

Ice Cap

MSRP

$43,630

Advertised

$44,120

New Castle, PA
Hold
2026 RAV4

2026 RAV4

RAV4 XSE AWD

+$490Fair

Storm Cloud with Midnight Black Metallic roof

MSRP

$47,069

Advertised

$47,559

New Castle, PA
Pre-SoldHold
2026 RAV4

2026 RAV4

RAV4 XLE Premium AWD

+$490Fair

Ice Cap

MSRP

$43,748

Advertised

$44,238

New Castle, PA
Hold
2026 RAV4

2026 RAV4

RAV4 Woodland AWD

+$490Fair

Urban Rock

MSRP

$42,769

Advertised

$43,259

New Castle, PA
2026 RAV4

2026 RAV4

RAV4 XSE AWD

+$490Fair

Midnight Black Metallic

MSRP

$45,419

Advertised

$45,909

New Castle, PA
Pre-SoldHold
2026 RAV4

2026 RAV4

RAV4 SE AWD

+$490Fair

Midnight Black Metallic

MSRP

$40,809

Advertised

$41,299

New Castle, PA
Hold
2026 RAV4

2026 RAV4

RAV4 XSE AWD

+$490Fair

Midnight Black Metallic

MSRP

$45,419

Advertised

$45,909

New Castle, PA
Pre-SoldHold
2026 RAV4

2026 RAV4

RAV4 Woodland AWD

+$490Fair

Urban Rock

MSRP

$42,570

Advertised

$43,060

New Castle, PA
Hold
2026 RAV4

2026 RAV4

RAV4 XSE AWD

+$490Fair

Meteor Shower with Midnight Black Metallic roof

MSRP

$46,579

Advertised

$47,069

New Castle, PA
Hold

Recently Sold

VehicleSelling PriceMarkupDays ListedSold Date
2027 Land CruiserLand Cruiser FT4WD$73,445+$49048Oct 22, 2026
2027 Land CruiserLand Cruiser FT4WD$73,520+$49084Oct 22, 2026
2026 SequoiaSequoia Platinum 4WD$86,483+$49046Oct 22, 2026
2026 SiennaSienna Limited AWD$59,284+$49048Oct 22, 2026
2026 SiennaSienna XLE AWD$52,270+$4907Oct 22, 2026
2026 SiennaSienna Platinum AWD$62,989-$51021Oct 22, 2026
2026 Corolla CrossCorolla Cross XLE AWD$35,899+$49046Oct 22, 2026
2026 Corolla CrossCorolla Cross LE AWD$33,088+$49022Oct 22, 2026
2026 Corolla CrossCorolla Cross LE AWD$32,623+$49027Oct 22, 2026
2026 Corolla CrossCorolla Cross LE AWD$33,088+$49027Oct 22, 2026