Matthews Subaru

Vestal, NY

Pricing posture

Does not price above MSRP

0% of this dealer's priced Subaru inventory is listed above MSRP — 0 of 75 vehicles.

Based on the advertised price in the manufacturer's public feed versus the factory window sticker. A dealer's final offer can differ. We only show this for brands whose feed publishes a real asking price that moves in both directions.

Vehicles

132

Avg Markup

-$1,679

At/Below MSRP

Models

Pricing by Model

Model	Count	At/Below MSRP	Avg Markup
Forester	44	100%	-$1,689
Crosstrek	43	100%	-$1,482
Outback	27	100%	-$2,012
WRX	6	100%	-$1,317
Ascent	6	100%	-$3,037
Impreza	5	100%	-$1,061
Trailseeker	1	100%	-$1,000

Below MSRP

2026 Ascent

Subaru

Touring 7-Passenger

-$4,030Good Deal

Sapphire Blue Pearl

MSRP

$53,782

Advertised

$49,752

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Limited

-$3,070Good Deal

Magnetite Gray Metallic

MSRP

$39,886

Advertised

$36,816

Vestal, NY

2026 Ascent

Subaru

Limited 7-Passenger

-$2,832Good Deal

Autumn Green Metallic

MSRP

$50,372

Advertised

$47,540

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Touring XT

-$2,658Good Deal

Crystal Black Silica

MSRP

$50,355

Advertised

$47,697

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Touring XT

-$2,658Good Deal

Crystal Black Silica

MSRP

$50,355

Advertised

$47,697

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$2,631Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$38,629

Advertised

$35,998

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Touring XT

-$2,614Good Deal

Crystal Black Silica

MSRP

$50,511

Advertised

$47,897

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Touring XT

-$2,355Good Deal

Ice Silver Metallic

MSRP

$50,153

Advertised

$47,798

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Touring XT

-$2,355Good Deal

Ice Silver Metallic

MSRP

$50,153

Advertised

$47,798

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Wilderness

-$2,303Good Deal

Magnetite Gray Metallic

MSRP

$49,299

Advertised

$46,996

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Wilderness

-$2,262Good Deal

Geyser Blue

MSRP

$49,026

Advertised

$46,764

Vestal, NY

2027 Ascent

Subaru

Limited Bronze Edition 7-Passenger

-$2,249Good Deal

Deepwater Blue Pearl

MSRP

$51,711

Advertised

$49,462

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Limited XT

-$2,133Good Deal

Sapphire Blue Pearl

MSRP

$46,577

Advertised

$44,444

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Limited

-$2,131Good Deal

Ice Silver Metallic

MSRP

$44,374

Advertised

$42,243

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Sport

-$2,073Good Deal

Sapphire Blue Pearl

MSRP

$39,396

Advertised

$37,323

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Limited

-$2,046Good Deal

Ice Silver Metallic

MSRP

$44,338

Advertised

$42,292

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Touring

-$2,045Good Deal

Crystal Black Silica

MSRP

$42,363

Advertised

$40,318

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Premium Hybrid

-$2,043Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$37,149

Advertised

$35,498

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Limited

-$2,024Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$39,963

Advertised

$37,939

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Touring Hybrid

-$2,003Good Deal

Autumn Green Metallic

MSRP

$43,882

Advertised

$41,879

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$2,000Good Deal

Daybreak Blue Pearl

MSRP

$41,525

Advertised

$39,525

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$2,000Good Deal

Magnetite Gray Metallic

MSRP

$40,455

Advertised

$39,332

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$1,972Good Deal

Ice Silver Metallic

MSRP

$37,467

Advertised

$35,495

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Sport

-$1,870Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$38,863

Advertised

$36,993

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Wilderness

-$1,842Good Deal

Geyser Blue

MSRP

$47,009

Advertised

$45,167

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Touring

-$1,819Good Deal

Crystal Black Silica

MSRP

$41,974

Advertised

$40,155

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Wilderness

-$1,794Good Deal

Ice Silver Metallic

MSRP

$37,695

Advertised

$35,901

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$1,762Good Deal

Magnetite Gray Metallic

MSRP

$40,736

Advertised

$38,974

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$1,725Good Deal

Ice Silver Metallic

MSRP

$39,223

Advertised

$37,498

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Wilderness

-$1,676Good Deal

Sapphire Blue Pearl

MSRP

$38,673

Advertised

$36,997

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Sport

-$1,670Good Deal

Magnetite Gray Metallic

MSRP

$38,863

Advertised

$37,193

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Premium

-$1,641Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$39,924

Advertised

$38,283

Vestal, NY

2026 Outback

Subaru

Premium

-$1,641Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$39,924

Advertised

$38,283

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited

-$1,626Good Deal

Sapphire Blue Pearl

MSRP

$36,919

Advertised

$35,293

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$1,594Good Deal

Sapphire Blue Pearl

MSRP

$39,067

Advertised

$37,473

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Sport

-$1,590Good Deal

Magnetite Gray Metallic

MSRP

$38,863

Advertised

$37,273

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Sport Hybrid

-$1,572Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$40,267

Advertised

$38,695

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Sport Hybrid

-$1,569Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$40,065

Advertised

$38,496

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$1,559Good Deal

Sand Dune Pearl

MSRP

$39,255

Advertised

$37,696

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Wilderness

-$1,534Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$37,897

Advertised

$36,363

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Limited

-$1,500Good Deal

Crystal Black Silica

MSRP

$38,051

Advertised

$36,551

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Premium Hybrid

-$1,500Good Deal

River Rock Pearl

MSRP

$37,462

Advertised

$35,962

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Premium

-$1,499Good Deal

Crystal Black Silica

MSRP

$34,730

Advertised

$33,231

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$1,474Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$37,467

Advertised

$35,993

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$1,474Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$37,467

Advertised

$35,993

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$1,469Good Deal

Sand Dune Pearl

MSRP

$37,862

Advertised

$36,393

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited Hybrid

-$1,463Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$37,260

Advertised

$35,797

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Premium

-$1,460Good Deal

River Rock Pearl

MSRP

$35,958

Advertised

$34,498

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited

-$1,425Good Deal

Magnetite Gray Metallic

MSRP

$36,919

Advertised

$35,494

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Limited

-$1,423Good Deal

Ice Silver Metallic

MSRP

$36,919

Advertised

$35,496

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Premium

-$1,413Good Deal

Magnetite Gray Metallic

MSRP

$32,681

Advertised

$31,268

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Premium Hybrid

-$1,378Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$37,067

Advertised

$35,689

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Wilderness

-$1,371Good Deal

Crystal White Pearl

MSRP

$38,153

Advertised

$36,782

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Sport Hybrid

-$1,370Good Deal

Sand Dune Pearl

MSRP

$36,660

Advertised

$35,290

Vestal, NY

2026 Forester

Subaru

Premium

-$1,365Good Deal

River Rock Pearl

MSRP

$34,758

Advertised

$33,393

Vestal, NY

2026 WRX

Subaru

Base

-$1,356Good Deal

Ceramic White

MSRP

$34,489

Advertised

$33,133

Vestal, NY

2026 WRX

Subaru

Premium

-$1,335Good Deal

Sapphire Blue Pearl

MSRP

$37,698

Advertised

$36,363

Vestal, NY

2026 WRX

Subaru

Base

-$1,313Good Deal

WR Blue Pearl

MSRP

$34,600

Advertised

$33,287

Vestal, NY

2026 Crosstrek

Subaru

Premium

-$1,283Good Deal

Alpine Green

MSRP

$33,076

Advertised

$31,793

Vestal, NY

2026 Impreza

Subaru

-$1,262Good Deal

Ice Silver Metallic

MSRP

$33,258

Advertised

$31,996

Vestal, NY

Recently Sold

Vehicle	Selling Price	Markup	Days Listed	Sold Date
2026 OutbackPremium	$37,873	-$1,786	69	Sep 27, 2026
2026 ForesterPremium	$33,169	-$1,194	58	Sep 27, 2026
2026 ForesterPremium	$34,728	-$1,230	48	Sep 27, 2026
2026 CrosstrekPremium	$31,913	-$1,163	34	Sep 27, 2026
2026 CrosstrekLimited Hybrid	$36,463	-$2,397	62	Sep 27, 2026
2026 CrosstrekPremium	$29,315	-$839	48	Sep 27, 2026
2026 OutbackLimited	$42,392	-$1,946	69	Sep 24, 2026
2026 OutbackLimited XT	$44,944	-$2,439	69	Sep 24, 2026
2026 ForesterPremium	$34,598	-$1,332	76	Sep 24, 2026
2026 ForesterPremium	$34,163	-$1,400	34	Sep 24, 2026